- Home
- FHA vs Conventional
FHA vs conventional: who FHA is really for.
"Just get a conventional loan" is great advice for some files and quietly devastating advice for others. Here is the honest map of when each one wins - including the part most comparisons skip.
The short version: conventional rewards the file you will have someday. FHA works with the file you have now.
"You didn't qualify for a conventional loan. Sorry."
You failed ONE rulebook. FHA is a different one:
- 580 score instead of 620
- 2-year bankruptcy wait instead of 4
- 3-year foreclosure wait instead of 7
- Higher debt ratios, gentler credit math
5.0 · 430+ Google reviews
Featured in Forbes, Money.com, Yahoo Finance, The Hill
Veteran-Owned · NMLS #1728740
FHA vs conventional at a glance
| What matters | FHA | Conventional |
|---|---|---|
| Minimum credit score | 580 (500 with 10% down) | 620 |
| Minimum down payment | 3.5% | 3% (first-time programs) to 5% |
| How your score prices the loan | Gently - rates stay close across scores | Heavily - lower scores pay real premiums |
| Mortgage insurance | MIP: 1.75% upfront + monthly; life of loan under 10% down | PMI: monthly only, cancels at 20% equity |
| Mortgage insurance pricing | Flat - same rate at 580 as at 740 | Score-based - expensive below ~680 |
| Debt-to-income ceiling | Up to 46.9% / 56.9% with strong factors | Typically capped near 45-50% |
| Wait after Chapter 7 | 2 years (12 months with extenuating) | 4 years |
| Wait after foreclosure | 3 years | 7 years (less with extenuating) |
| Human underwriting option | Yes - a real manual underwrite path | Rare in practice |
| Occupancy | Primary residence only | Primary, second homes, investment |
FHA figures per HUD Handbook 4000.1; conventional figures reflect standard agency guidelines. Subject to eligibility and lender guidelines; individual lender overlays vary.
MIP vs PMI: the real trade
Both loans charge you for a small down payment - they just charge differently, and the difference decides winners.
FHA's MIP is two parts: 1.75% of the loan upfront (almost always financed in) plus roughly 0.50% to 0.55% a year, paid monthly. It does not care what your credit score is - 580 pays the same MIP rate as 740. The catch: with less than 10% down, it stays for the life of the loan. You typically shed it later by refinancing once your equity and score have grown.
Conventional PMI is monthly only and it disappears on its own - you can request cancellation at 20% equity, and it auto-terminates at 78%. But PMI is priced on your credit score, and below roughly 680 it gets expensive fast. A 640 buyer with 5% down often pays more each month for PMI than they ever would for MIP - on top of a higher rate.
That is the pattern under all the noise: conventional's advantages are real, but they are reserved for strong-score, bigger-down files. The weaker the file, the more FHA's flat pricing wins.
When each one actually wins
We arrange both every week. This is the pattern, with no dog in the fight:
Conventional usually wins when you have...
- A credit score around 720 or higher - you earn the good rate AND cheap PMI
- 10% to 20% down - PMI gets small or disappears entirely
- A clean credit history with no recent derogatory events
- Plans to keep the loan long-term - PMI cancels, MIP mostly does not
- A second home or investment property in mind - FHA will not do those
FHA usually wins when you have...
- A score between 500 and about 680 - flat MIP + gentler rate pricing beats score-punished PMI
- A bankruptcy or foreclosure in your recent past - FHA's clocks are years shorter
- Higher debt ratios - FHA's automated approvals stretch further
- A gifted down payment or a non-occupant co-borrower helping you qualify
- Thin or no credit - FHA's manual underwrite path was built for you
The middle band - roughly 680 to 720 with 5% down - is a genuine coin flip that depends on the month's pricing and your exact file. That one is worth 15 minutes with a broker who can price both, not a blog's guess.
FHA now does not mean FHA forever
The most useful way to think about this choice: conventional is a destination, FHA is a door. Plenty of our buyers use FHA at 610 with 3.5% down, spend two years living in their own home while their score climbs and their equity grows, then refinance into a conventional loan and drop the MIP.
Renting for three more years to "save up for conventional" usually costs far more than MIP ever will - you pay 100% interest on rent. The math on waiting is almost never as kind as it feels.
Denied for conventional? That was not a mortgage denial.
A conventional denial means you missed one rulebook's cutoffs - a 620 floor, a 4-year bankruptcy clock, a DTI cap. FHA runs on different numbers on every one of those lines, and it adds a human review path conventional barely has.
Find the exact reason you were declined on the denial diagnosis index, or go straight to the FHA requirements and see how differently your file reads. If the computer is the one saying no, manual underwriting is the door most people were never shown.
FHA vs conventional, asked and answered
Are FHA rates higher than conventional rates?
Often the opposite - FHA base rates frequently run at or below conventional. The full cost picture depends on mortgage insurance on both sides, which is why comparing "the rate" alone misleads. At lower credit scores, FHA's gentler pricing usually wins the total-payment math.
Is it harder to win a house offer with FHA financing?
In hot markets some listing agents wrongly treat FHA offers as weaker, usually over appraisal fears. A strong preapproval letter, a clean timeline, and an agent who can speak to the file closes most of that gap. The financing type matters far less than the offer's preparation.
Can I switch from FHA to conventional later?
Yes - that is the standard playbook. Once your equity reaches about 20% and your score has climbed, refinancing to conventional removes MIP entirely. FHA is how many buyers start; it is rarely how they finish.
Do FHA and conventional use the same appraisal?
No. FHA appraisals include minimum property requirements - safety, security, soundness checks that conventional appraisals do not enforce. If the property is rough, that difference can matter more than anything about your file. See FHA property requirements.
I was told FHA is "for people with bad credit." True?
FHA is for people whose files do not fit conventional's narrow scoring - which includes plenty of careful, budget-disciplined people with a thin file, a past hardship, or self-employment income. It is a different rulebook, not a lower class of loan. It is also the largest single source of first-time-buyer mortgages in America.
Want the answer for your actual file?
As a broker we price both FHA and conventional across wholesale lenders and show you the math side by side. Fifteen minutes settles what a comparison page never can.
Or call (843) 569-7283 / 843.LOW.RATE