- Home
- FHA With Collections, Charge-Offs & Judgments
Collections on your report? FHA has a rule for that - and it is kinder than the no you got. Here is your yes.
FHA does not require most collections to be paid. Medical collections are excluded entirely. Charge-offs get their own gentler rule. The lender who told you to "come back when it's all paid off" skipped the actual handbook.
Rules below come from HUD Handbook 4000.1, in plain English. Subject to eligibility and lender guidelines.
"Pay off all your collections first, then we'll talk."
The handbook says otherwise:
- Most collections never have to be paid
- Medical collections are excluded entirely
- Charge-offs: no payoff, no penalty math
- Only judgments truly demand a plan
5.0 · 430+ Google reviews
Featured in Forbes, Money.com, Yahoo Finance, The Hill
Veteran-Owned · NMLS #1728740
The $2,000 rule, in plain English
Here is the whole FHA collections rule most loan officers never read to the end. Add up the outstanding balances of your non-medical collection accounts - across everyone on the loan. If the total is under $2,000, FHA requires nothing. No payoffs, no penalty, no drama.
If the total is $2,000 or more, you get three options, and paying everything off is only one of them. Option one: pay the collections in full at or before closing. Option two: set up a verified payment arrangement and count that monthly payment in your DTI. Option three - the one nobody mentions - pay nothing, and let the lender count 5% of each collection's outstanding balance in your DTI as if it were a monthly payment. On $4,000 of collections, that is a $200 monthly placeholder. If your income can carry it, the collections stay unpaid and you still close.
And two whole categories sit outside this math entirely: medical collections, which FHA excludes on purpose, and charge-offs, which require no payoff and no 5% treatment at all.
Four account types, four different rules
The words on your credit report decide the rule that applies. Sort your derogatory accounts into these buckets before you believe any denial:
Medical collections
Excluded from the $2,000 calculation entirely. The ER bill that went to collections during the worst year of your life does not block an FHA loan, and you do not have to pay it off to qualify.
Non-medical collections
The old phone bill, the apartment move-out charge, the credit card that went to a collector. These are the accounts the $2,000 rule measures - and even over the line, the 5%-to-DTI option means "unpaid" can still close.
Charge-offs
A debt the original creditor wrote off. FHA requires no payoff and does not put charge-offs through the 5% math. On a manual underwrite, expect to write a short letter explaining what happened - that is the whole ask.
Judgments
The one category with teeth, because a court is involved. Judgments must be paid off, or under a written payment agreement with at least 3 months of on-time payments already made before closing - and you cannot prepay three months in a lump to skip the wait.
From messy report to closable file, step by step
Inventory and sort
Pull all three bureaus and label every derogatory account: medical collection, non-medical collection, charge-off, or judgment. This ten-minute sort usually shrinks the "problem" dramatically - medical and charge-offs come off the worry list immediately.
The move
Total only the non-medical collection balances. Under $2,000? Your collections require zero action. Over it? Move to step 2 with the real number in hand.
Timeline: one eveningChoose your $2,000-rule option like a strategist
Payoff, payment plan, or the 5% DTI hit - the right answer is math, not morals. If your DTI has room, taking the 5% hit and paying nothing is often the cleanest close. If the DTI is tight, a small payment plan beats a full payoff that drains your reserves.
The move
Run all three versions of your DTI before touching a dollar. Cash you keep in the bank can double as reserves - which strengthens the whole file, especially on a manual underwrite.
Timeline: one strategy callPut judgments on rails early
Because judgments need three timely payments on a written agreement before closing, this is the one item with a real clock. Start it the day you decide to buy, not the week you find a house.
The move
Contact the judgment creditor, get the agreement in writing, and make the payments on schedule - three months later this stops being a blocker. Paying it off in full at closing also works if the cash is there.
Timeline: 3 months minimum on the plan pathDo not wake sleeping debts without a plan
Two traps to skip: disputing your way into a downgrade, and paying old collections carelessly. Disputed derogatory accounts totaling $1,000 or more push the file out of automated approval into manual underwriting - fine if you are ready for it, a surprise if you are not. And a payment on a very old collection can restart its activity date without helping your score.
The move
Dispute only genuine errors and documented identity theft. For everything real, use the $2,000-rule options above - they exist so you do not have to fight every account.
Timeline: avoids 30-60 days of self-inflicted delayCollections often route to a manual underwrite - and that is a door, not a wall
Bigger collection balances, disputed accounts, and the letters of explanation they require frequently move a file from the computer to a human underwriter. Here is what the human needs to see - Jason's 5 things:
"Here are the 5 things, that if I have them, I can promise you I can close your loan."
Jason Sharon · Mortgage Broker, NMLS #1281448 · Home Loans Inc, Company NMLS #1728740
- No late payments on your credit report in the last 12 months. Zip, zilch, nada, none.
- Up to 2 thirty-day lates in the last 24 months. Not 3 thirty-day lates, not 1 sixty-day late.
- 12 months of verifiable on-time rent: a ledger from your complex, 12 cleared checks, or proof rent was paid in the month due.
- 2x the new mortgage payment in savings beyond your down payment and closing costs - saved by you, not gifted.
- Stable job history. No hopping, no large unexplained gaps.
Jason's promise reflects how these files actually close. All loans remain subject to eligibility, underwriting approval, and lender guidelines.
Related denial reasons
Your credit score is too low
Collections usually drag a score with them. FHA allows 580 with 3.5% down - and 500 with 10% down. The real cutoffs and the fastest fixes.
See the path →A recent bankruptcy
Chapter 7 waits 2 years from discharge - sometimes 12 months. Chapter 13 can qualify while still in the plan.
See the path →Every FHA denial reason
The complete diagnosis index - find any reason you were given and the exact path back to yes.
See all reasons →What people ask about collections and FHA
Do I have to pay off collections to get an FHA loan?
Usually not. If your non-medical collections total under $2,000, FHA requires nothing at all. Over $2,000, you choose: pay them, set up a payment plan, or simply let the lender count 5% of the balances in your DTI and leave them unpaid. Medical collections are excluded from the math entirely.
Do medical collections count against me?
FHA excludes medical collections from its $2,000 collections rule - they do not have to be paid and do not trigger the 5% DTI treatment. If a lender denied you over medical debt alone, get a second opinion on the file, because HUD's handbook is specifically gentler here.
What is the difference between a collection and a charge-off for FHA?
A collection is a debt a collector is actively pursuing; a charge-off is a debt the original creditor wrote off its books. FHA treats charge-offs more gently: no required payoff and no 5% DTI math. On a manual underwrite you may write a short letter of explanation, and that is typically the whole requirement.
I have a judgment. Is FHA off the table?
No, but judgments are the one category with a real requirement: pay it off, or get a written payment agreement and make at least 3 on-time monthly payments before closing. You cannot prepay the 3 months in one lump sum to skip the clock - so start the agreement early.
Should I dispute everything on my report before applying?
No. Disputed derogatory accounts with balances totaling $1,000 or more push your file out of the automated system into a manual underwrite. That is workable, but it should be a choice, not an accident. Dispute genuine errors and documented identity theft; use FHA's own options for the accounts that are real.
Bring us the messy report. We sort it for a living.
In one call we bucket every account, run the $2,000 math, and tell you exactly what has to be paid, planned, or left alone. Most reports are more closable than their owners think.
Or call (843) 569-7283 / 843.LOW.RATE